The Greenbergian Word Order Correlations
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper reports on the results of a detailed empirical study of word order correlations, based on a sample of 625 languages. The primary result is a determination of exactly what pairs of elements correlate in order with the verb and object. Some pairs of elements that have been claimed to correlate in order with the verb and object do not in fact exhibit any correlation. I argue against the Head-Dependent Theory (HDT), according to which the correlations reflect a tendency towards consistent ordering of heads and dependents. I offer an alternative account, the Branching Direction Theory (BDT), based on consistent ordering of phrasal and nonphrasal elements. According to the BDT, the word order correlations reflect a tendency for languages to be consistently rightbranching or consistently left-branching.*
منابع مشابه
The Evolution of the Greenbergian Word Order Correlations
Recurring traits across languages have been argued to relate directly to constraints imposed by the brain. A particular case is Greenberg's word order universals (Greenberg 1966), which have been argued to reflect the demands of language acquisition (Baker 2001, Chomsky 2010) or of processing sentences (Hawkins 1983, Kirby and Hurford 1997). This paper argues that typological universals are ind...
متن کاملOn the Parallelism of DPs and Clauses: Evidence from Kisongo Maasai version of 9/12/2003
There are well-known word order correlations between clauses and DPs, with clausal VS(O) order correlating with nominal NS(O) order, and, less strongly, with NA order. Of the 53 V1 languages listed in Hawkins (1983) for example, 51 have NG word order, and 38 NA order. These correlations can be illustrated for Kisongo Maasai, an Eastern Nilotic language with strict VSO word order, and (Dem) N (N...
متن کاملLanguage Change as a Source of Word Order Correlations∗
Typological work has demonstrated that there are constraints on word order variation. For example, auxiliary verbs tend to precede content verbs in VO languages (Dryer 1992). Further, typologically recurrent structural preferences are reflected in language change. In this paper, we present agent-based modeling work that suggests that Filtered Learning Models (e.g. Kirby 1999) can capture the em...
متن کاملThe effect of canonical word order on the production and comprehension of pseudoclefts in L2
This study investigated the effect of word order and age on the production and comprehension of pseudoclefts in L2 across two experiments. For each experiment 16 female students aged between 179 and 210 months were recruited from a secondary school. These students were divided into two groups based on their age range; one group for investigating the effect of word order and age on the productio...
متن کاملDescriptive and Explanatory Markedness
The wide empirical coverage of two number features, [±singular] and [±augmented], is used to show that (Greenbergian) category-internal markedness, (geometric) feature markedness, and value markedness are, respectively, epiphenomenal, untenable, and too simplistically formulated to be currently evaluated.
متن کامل